Category: Blog

Is Your Claims Data Ready for Value-Based Care?

June 1, 2026|

Claims data is ready for value-based care when it is complete, reconciled to final-action claims, validated, standardized, and normalized, and prepared in the format each downstream system requires. Loading payer files into an analytics platform is the start. When numbers don’t tie across finance, analytics, and clinical teams, the data often wasn’t ready before it was loaded, or it was prepared in more than one place. An analytics vendor, an internal team, and a data partner may each transform the same payer data with different validation logic and load methods, then load it into different systems, so each system shows a different version of the same claims.

Claims data captures care delivered across settings for an attributed population. When it is reliable, it supports quality reporting, shared savings calculations, risk stratification, care gap closure, provider scorecards, and contract discussions. When it isn’t, those same tools can mislead the people who depend on them, often without anyone noticing until the numbers are compared and questioned.

Why does claims data often fall short in value-based care?

Claims data often falls short because each payer sends it differently, and the data itself can change from cycle to cycle. Health system leaders rely on it heavily, yet many aren’t confident in it.

In HDI’s 2025 market report, 87% of C-suite hospital and health system leaders said claims data is important to value-based care success, and 74% said their executive leadership relies on it for strategic decisions. Only 35% were highly confident in the quality of the data they use. The same research found that 91% of organizations find it challenging to reliably integrate and validate claims data, and nearly half said it takes five or more months to onboard data from a single new payer.

These challenges appear in well-resourced organizations too. They come from the nature of claims data. File layouts, field definitions, code usage, and update schedules vary by payer, and payers can change them with limited or no notice. A format that worked last month may break this month, undetected until the numbers look wrong.

Industry groups see the same pattern. In their voluntary best practices for data sharing, AHIP, the American Medical Association, and the National Association of ACOs note that early value-based care contracts were built “plan-by-plan, contract-by-contract,” and that variation across payers increases “the time and resources needed for providers to monitor, analyze, and act on the data.”

Why do claims data results change from one cycle to the next?

Claims data changes because a single claim can move through submission, adjudication, adjustments, and reversals over 60 to 90 days, with several parties shaping its final form. If a process captures claims at one point in time, results can shift later in ways teams struggle to explain.

A claim changing over time is a normal part of claims data. What counts is whether your process tracks each change against what was received before and reflects the current state of each claim, for both utilization and cost. When it does, performance results still update, but your team can explain the change and stand behind it.

What does it cost when claims data isn’t ready for value-based care?

The costs show up in time, confidence, and results. Analysts spend time chasing missing files, working through payer-specific issues, and tracing whether an error sits in the raw file or in their own process. That is time taken from the analysis and performance improvement work they were hired to do.

Bad data that gets into downstream systems creates larger problems. Provider scorecards built on incorrect claims expose organizations to risk. Quality measures in value-based care contracts can hinge on a handful of patients, so care teams need claims data that shows them who those patients are. Christopher Ragsdale, Founder and Principal of Towers Advisory, described what reaching one benchmark was worth:

“There was one instance where a care coordinator was able to identify care gaps and chase down just a few more patients. That got us to the 90th percentile benchmark, which made the difference of nearly $1 million in incremental revenue on that value based care contract.” — Christopher Ragsdale, Founder and Principal, Towers Advisory

When clinicians see numbers they can’t trust, they may stop using the dashboards, and that trust is hard to rebuild.

AI raises the stakes. An AI model doesn’t correct incomplete or unreliable data; it carries the same gaps into its output, faster and with more apparent certainty. Reliable claims data is a prerequisite for AI initiatives that use it.

What does claims data need before it is ready for value-based care?

Before claims data is loaded into downstream systems, it needs to meet five conditions. Missing any one of them can change denominator counts, misstate utilization or spend, shift quality measure performance, or weaken risk adjustment.

  • As complete as possible: the right population over the right time period, with the required fields available, and a clear accounting of anything the source didn’t provide
  • Reconciled: adjustments, reversals, and denials resolved to final-action claims
  • Validated: checked for reliable analytic results, not only format compliance
  • Standardized and normalized: consistent structure and layout across payers, aligned so data from each source speaks the same language
  • Prepared for each downstream system: in the format each system requires, from EHRs such as Epic to data warehouses, analytics tools, and workflow tools

When one of these is missing, the problems rarely look serious on their own. They pull teams into ongoing data reconciliation instead of performance improvement, slow decisions, and can surface months later, when fixing them costs far more than preventing them would have.

What changes when claims data is ready for value-based care?

When claims data is ready, leaders spend less time questioning the numbers and more time acting on them. Finance, analytics, and clinical teams work from the same version of the claims, so discussions focus on performance rather than on whose numbers are right. Analysts can return to analysis, and value-based care leaders can step back from day-to-day monitoring of payer files.

Health system leaders who work with a specialist partner describe the change in their own words. An Associate CIO, whose claims data implementation was at risk of failing, described what changed once a specialist partner took on the work:

“It was just a relief. The confidence was immediately there. We felt that we were in good hands.”

— Associate CIO, Regional Health System

A VP of Value-Based Care described stepping back after a couple of weeks:

“I had been able to really disengage and not pay as close attention.”

— VP of Value-Based Care

Some of the change is simply seeing what was missing. A value-based care manager at a large health system in the Southeast said:

“I don’t think any of us realized how frequently we had missed files from the payers until we started interacting with HDI.” — Manager, Value-Based Care, large health system in the Southeast

Preparing claims data well is ongoing work. Payer format changes, validation, anomaly detection, and claims reconciliation continue with each new file. If your team is weighing how to manage that work, it helps to know what a partner for healthcare claims data integration should handle.

How does Health Data Innovations (HDI) help make claims data ready for value-based care?

Health Data Innovations (HDI) manages the complex work of external healthcare data aggregation and validation. We acquire, validate, standardize, and normalize claims data from each payer with each new file, document issues for correction at the source, and reprocess corrected files, delivering a reliable single source of truth for all downstream systems, including EHRs such as Epic, data warehouses, analytics tools, and workflow tools. HDI has worked with 627+ data vendors, and our External Data Management services help health systems use claims data in value-based care with confidence.

See how other health system leaders rate their confidence in claims data, and where the biggest challenges sit, in HDI’s 2025 market report.

Read the 2025 market report

Frequently asked questions about claims data for value-based care

What makes claims data ready for value-based care?

Claims data is ready for value-based care when it is as complete as possible, reconciled to final-action claims, validated, standardized, and normalized, and prepared in the format each downstream system requires before it is loaded.

Why do value-based care results change after the fact?

Claims can change from cycle to cycle as they move through adjudication, adjustments, and reversals over 60 to 90 days. Results stay explainable when each change is tracked against what was received before.